If your December or January power bill came in at close to double what you were paying in October, two things are true at once. Most of the time that is normal and your system is fine. Some of the time it is the first visible symptom of a heating problem that has been building quietly since fall. Almost nothing written on this subject helps you tell which one you are looking at.
Here is the test, and it takes about five minutes with two bills in front of you.
Stop comparing dollars. Compare kilowatt-hours. Dollars move for reasons that have nothing to do with your house: the rate changes, and billing cycles are not the same length. Kilowatt-hours are the actual amount of electricity your home used. Put last winter's kilowatt-hours next to this winter's, then look at how cold the two months actually were. If usage rose roughly in step with the weather, you are paying for January and there is nothing to fix. If usage jumped much harder than the weather did, something in your heating system is working harder than it should be, and that is worth a phone call.
The Short Answer
- Heating is the largest thing on a winter bill in this part of Alabama, and most homes around Cullman heat with electricity, so the whole increase lands on one bill instead of being split with a gas bill.
- A heat pump running on its backup heat strips costs roughly three to five times what the heat pump costs on its own. That ratio is why a bill can double with nothing visibly broken.
- Compare kilowatt-hours, not dollars, and compare the same month last year, not last month. December against November tells you nothing except that December is colder.
- The question is not whether the bill went up. It is whether it went up more than the weather did.
Why a Cullman Winter Bill Climbs Even When Nothing Is Wrong
Three ordinary things stack up every December and January, and none of them means anything is broken.
The weather does most of it. Here are the 1991 to 2020 climate normals for Cullman, from the NOAA climate normals for Cullman:
| Month | Average high | Average low |
|---|---|---|
| December | 53°F | 32°F |
| January | 50°F | 30°F |
| February | 55°F | 33°F |
A January day here averages right around 40°F. In October your house barely asks for heat at all, and on plenty of October days the system never runs. In January it runs most of the night and a good part of the day. That is not a modest change in workload, it is a change from almost nothing to the heaviest load of the year, and a large jump in the bill is the correct outcome.
The billing cycle is not always the same length. A 33 day December cycle against a 28 day November cycle is 18 percent more days of everything before a single degree of weather is accounted for. The number of days is printed on your bill. Check it before you panic.
The rate can change. Cullman Electric Cooperative's residential rate has run in the neighborhood of 13 cents per kilowatt-hour, and the co-op has adjusted rates in recent years. Use the actual rate printed on your own bill rather than any number you read online, including ours. If the rate moved and your usage did not, that is a billing question for the co-op, not a heating question for us.
The Weather Test
Heating load tracks how far the outdoor temperature sits below about 65°F, which is roughly the point where a house stops needing heat. The colder the month, the bigger that gap, and the harder your system works.
You do not need to calculate anything. Just put the two numbers side by side and ask whether they move together.
What a normal increase looks like:
| Last January | This January | |
|---|---|---|
| Kilowatt-hours used | 1,900 | 2,350 |
| Days in the cycle | 30 | 31 |
| How the month felt | cold | noticeably colder |
Usage up about 24 percent in a month that was genuinely colder and one day longer. The weather explains it. Nothing to do.
What a problem looks like:
| Last January | This January | |
|---|---|---|
| Kilowatt-hours used | 1,900 | 3,600 |
| Days in the cycle | 30 | 30 |
| How the month felt | cold | about the same |
Usage nearly doubled in a month that was not meaningfully colder, over the same number of days. The weather does not explain that. Something else does.
Those are illustrations, not readings from a real account, but the shape is what matters. Most power companies, including Cullman Electric, show usage history in the online account, so you can usually pull twelve or twenty four months of kilowatt-hours without digging through paper.
One honest caveat: if you moved in, added a room, finished a basement, bought a hot tub or started working from home since last winter, your baseline changed and the comparison will not be clean. Compare what you can and weigh the rest.
The Signs That Point at the Heating System
Run the weather test first. If usage outran the weather, these are the things that tell you it is the heating system and not something else in the house:
- AUX HEAT or EM HEAT showing on the thermostat in mild weather. This is the single most useful observation you can make. Those backup strips are essentially large toasters, and they are the most expensive heat in your house.
- The system runs nonstop at 50°F or warmer outdoors. At that temperature a healthy heat pump should be cycling comfortably.
- The house never quite reaches the temperature you set, or takes hours to recover after you raise it.
- Air from the vents feels cooler than it used to even when the system has been running a while.
- The outdoor unit is buried in solid ice, rather than carrying the light frost that is normal between defrost cycles.
- Rooms that used to be comfortable are now noticeably colder than the rest of the house.
Any one of those alongside a bill that outran the weather is worth a diagnostic visit rather than a wait-and-see. A winter of strip heat costs far more than finding out what is wrong.
Bill went up more than the weather did? Call us at (256) 915-2826. We will check the refrigerant charge, the airflow, the defrost cycle and how your thermostat brings in the backup heat, and quote any repair before we start. Veterans Cooling and Heating is veteran-owned, licensed in Alabama (AL#24210), with 15+ years in the trade, handling heating repair across Cullman County and the surrounding communities.
Ready for honest, dependable HVAC service?
Talk to a real veteran-owned local team. Same-day service available.
What We Actually Find When Usage Outruns the Weather
When we go out on a bill complaint in January, it is almost never a dramatic failure. It is usually something that has been quietly costing money since the fall.
A slow refrigerant leak. This is the most common one, and it is the sneakiest, because the house still gets warm. A low charge reduces the heat pump's capacity, so it cannot keep up in weather it handled fine last year, and the backup strips step in to cover the shortfall. Nothing sounds wrong, nothing smells wrong, and the only evidence is the bill. Checking a charge takes gauges and a license, which is why this one almost never gets caught by a homeowner.
Restricted airflow. A filter that has not been changed since summer, a dirty indoor coil, closed registers, or furniture over a return. The system runs longer to move the same heat, and in a heat pump that often means the strips run too. This is the cheapest thing on the list to fix and the most commonly ignored.
A defrost cycle that is not working right. Frost builds on the outdoor coil in our damp winters, and the system is supposed to reverse briefly to melt it off. A failing defrost board or sensor means either too many defrost cycles, which each fire the strips, or not enough, which lets the coil ice over and strangle the system.
Thermostat staging set wrong. The thermostat decides when the strips are allowed to come on. We find settings that bring them in far too early, sometimes left over from an installation or a thermostat replacement. The house stays warm, so nobody notices until the bill arrives. Setting the strips to hold off until they are genuinely needed can be the whole fix.
Emergency heat left on. Someone switched the system to EM HEAT during a cold snap, the weather warmed up, and nobody switched it back. That shuts the heat pump off entirely and runs the house on the most expensive heat it has, for as long as it is left there. It is worth walking to the thermostat right now and looking. If you are not sure what you are looking at, we wrote up the difference between auxiliary heat and emergency heat, including what each one costs per hour.
Things That Raise a Winter Bill and Have Nothing to Do With Your Heating
We would rather you check these before you call us, because for a good share of people this is the whole answer.
Space heaters. This is the big one and the arithmetic is brutal. A typical plug-in space heater draws 1,500 watts. Run one ten hours a day for a month and that is roughly 450 kilowatt-hours, which at a rate near 13 cents comes to about $60 on a single bill. Two of them in two cold bedrooms, and you have added something close to $120. They feel cheap because they were cheap to buy. They are the most expensive heat in the house, the same resistance heat as the backup strips, and a cold room that needs one every night is usually telling you something about airflow or the balance of the system.
The water heater. Groundwater is colder in winter, so an electric water heater has further to go on every tank and runs noticeably longer than it did in August. Add holiday guests taking showers and the increase is real. If yours is also making noise, taking longer to recover, or running out sooner than it used to, that is a separate conversation and we handle water heaters too.
Holidays. Extra people in the house, the oven running for hours, and outdoor lights on a timer all land on the December bill and all disappear in January.
More days in the cycle. Already mentioned, and worth the ten seconds it takes to check.
What You Can Check Yourself in Fifteen Minutes
Before you call anyone, five things, all free:
- Look at the thermostat. Is it on EM HEAT? Is AUX showing right now, and what is the temperature outside? That single observation tells a technician a great deal before anyone opens a panel.
- Pull the filter and hold it to a light. If light does not pass through easily, replace it. It is the cheapest fix on this list by a wide margin.
- Walk the house. Open closed registers, pull rugs and furniture off vents and return grilles. Closing vents in unused rooms does not save money, it raises duct pressure and makes the system work harder.
- Look at the outdoor unit. Clear leaves and pine straw, give it two feet of space, and do not cover or wrap it for winter. A heat pump has to breathe all season. A light coat of frost is fine. A solid block of ice is not.
- Count the space heaters and be honest about how long they run.
Our fall and spring maintenance checklist goes through the rest of what a homeowner can do and where the line is.
What is not a homeowner job: checking the refrigerant charge, setting the aux lockout or balance point, testing the defrost board, and anything involving the heat strips, which run on high voltage circuits. Those need gauges, meters and a license.
When It Is Worth a Service Call
Call when usage outran the weather and you can point at one of the heating signs above. Call sooner if the house is not holding the temperature you set, if aux heat shows in mild weather, or if the outdoor unit is iced solid.
The reason not to wait is arithmetic rather than alarm. A diagnostic visit is a fixed, known cost. A heating system limping along on backup heat is an open-ended one that runs until the weather breaks in March. If your system is also old enough that you are weighing repairs against replacement, that decision has its own four questions. And if your heat pump seems to run constantly on cold nights, read why that is usually correct in North Alabama before you assume the bill is its fault.
Have Someone Look at It
Veterans Cooling and Heating is a veteran-owned, licensed Alabama HVAC contractor (AL#24210) with 15+ years in the trade, serving Cullman, Hanceville, Good Hope, Vinemont, Holly Pond, Fairview, Baileyton, West Point, Joppa and Arab. Bring your last two bills to the appointment if you have them. We will check the charge, the airflow, the defrost cycle and how your thermostat is bringing in the backup heat, and tell you straight whether your bill is the weather or the equipment.
Call (256) 915-2826 or request service online. We are open Monday through Friday, 7 AM to 6 PM. A heating tune-up catches most of what is on this page, our current specials are worth a look before you book, and if a repair turns into a bigger conversation there is financing.

